|
Post by Admin on Jan 18, 2017 12:14:17 GMT -4
|
|
|
Post by Connie Lapadat on Jan 18, 2017 15:49:08 GMT -4
With babyboomers retiring and the 'latchkey' generation X (work hard: play hard motto) falling into those retired positions the milleniums will be the main group contributing to the economy. Mentioned in the article is the stress that millenials experience from generation X'ers and babyboomers putting pressure on them to work, work, work when in fact the view of a balanced life view amongst millenials should eventually equate to less stress in the job place. With the advent of advanced telecommunication technology and emails, one would predict that less time would need to be dedicated to driving to meetings, after hour meetings, and petty office tasks that have encumbered babyboomers in the past. Technology leaves more time to do actual work, such as seeing patients, and can afford a more balanced work day schedule. Millenials need to be cautious about texting as a solo means of communication as Seltzer in later publications comments how texting not only releases a dopamine high but also the love hormone, oxytocin is released! In as much as coffee increasing dopamine receptors in the brain and is being implemented to treat mild ADHD, texting also will increase receptors in our tubulofundibular pathway creating a dependance. Can texting withdrawal be considered as a physiological stress trigger for depression, anxiety, bipolar? Interesting, Seltzer (2009) continues to comment that young 'tweens' who texted their mothers after a test felt less relaxed than when they called their mother. Perhaps, this proposes a necessary chemical need from our brains for human interaction and the soon to be obsolete phone call!! Is this the contribution to more millenials suffering with mental health disorders...??
|
|
|
Post by Brice Burke on Jan 18, 2017 17:39:47 GMT -4
Personally I do not care for being categorized as a millennial. I think there may be some generational similarities, but there is a quite a bit of variation in each generation. In spite of that, I did find the article interesting. In particular the part when it mentions that social media may be contributing to ‘millenials’ depression. I agree that social media is like a highlight real. The over arching theme is ‘look what I have done or will get to do’. Personally I did a like case study on myself. I found myself slipping into a dysthymic mood when studying constantly for step 1. I was on social media more often watching peoples highlight reals. I ended up cutting off social media for the several weeks, and my mood improved. I no longer saw my friends in Paris as I was in a basement studying. This articles made this point very clearly, and I appreciated reading it.
|
|
|
Post by Caroly Lenz-Tucker on Jan 18, 2017 19:04:31 GMT -4
The article was insightful. As a mother of 5 millennials, My take on the depression that haunts this generation is the instant gratification they have had through their lives. In previous generations, the focus was on meeting needs. Because our economy had grown so well during the '80's and 90's, we were able to give our children what they wanted, not just needed. Then, they were raised with the advent of the electronic era where wants were met at a much faster rate, frequently instantaneously. This is echoed in the article where he talks about the good feelings coming from the responses to posts. In a real world situation, instant gratification is impossible on the grand scale of the work place. In addition to the gratification, millennials also seem to need daily recognition. When instant gratification and/or recognition is lacking on a daily scale, some of these millennials sink into depression. Frustration with the obvious, has led me personally, to more of an angry response to this behavior, in the past. So, this article sheds some light on the topic. Why they are not seeking care, is another topic of debate. Is it because insurance may not cover psychiatric care? (Obamacare was supposed to mandate coverage on all policies when it took effect) Or is the reason they do not seek care altogether different such as lack of insight or more severe psychiatric disorders underlying their depression? This is, without a doubt, a good topic for research.
|
|
|
Post by Noura Eleid on Jan 18, 2017 23:19:33 GMT -4
I agree with the final statement of this article, i.e. that the cause of depression needs to be examined and that our modern lifestyle also needs to be scrutinized as a “proximate cause.” But, I’m not sure about the author’s proposal to overturn the business culture to suit the sentiments of the millennial group, or her emphasis on the “basic dignity of a flexible work schedule” – even if this is a Forbes article. I raised an eyebrow at that one and it prompted me to read the author’s bio – lo and behold, she’s a millennial! She touches on our still-evolving relationship to technology and the cesspool of social media - which is relevant considering that the average American today knows more about what Miley Cyrus had for breakfast than what’s going on in their own ‘backyard.’ But, is this just another branch of the sickly tree? I’m not sure this article touches on the root of the problem. I’m far more interested in the question of why the incidence of depression continues to increase from generation to generation in this country. How much, for instance, does the post-modern movement, the questioning of objective truth and reality, the growth of moral relativism and pluralism that developed in the mid to late 20th century play into our modern day mentality and the increasing incidence of depression? Did it mark the beginning of some sort of 'domino-effect' of meaninglessness that has ultimately left so many struggling to find their purpose and break themselves out of apathy? Depression is indeed a disease, but it’s one whose treatment outcomes with antidepressant therapy are identical to that of ‘talk-therapy.’ What does that say about its nature?
|
|
Chaminda Dissanayake (MS3-AUIS
Guest
|
Post by Chaminda Dissanayake (MS3-AUIS on Jan 18, 2017 23:54:47 GMT -4
This article touches upon not only a very important topic, depression, but also upon both the neurological and also environmental influences that play a role in creating depression. While technology, and as a natural extension, social media, may have made things 'easier' per se, in terms of being able to communicate with one another, what is important to be cognizant of is that this is a double edged sword. The article mentioned, for instance, how we have become so involved in the various forms of social media and therefore continue to be inundated by 'updates' of how our peers are doing. This can easily lead to feelings of inadequacy and ultimately, at least contribute to the environmental role of developing depression. I commend the fact that society is now shifting the tide, into recognizing how depression is a serious medical illness which can be debilitating for the patient and also affect his or her loved ones. The older generation, as in the baby boomers, would place too little emphasis, if any at all, on the role of mental health as a whole. I believe that as time progresses, more and more credence will be given to the validity of depression and mental health, and more attention will be paid to the societal/environmental factors that contribute to its etiology as well.
|
|
Amelia Harvey (Mercer PA)
Guest
|
Post by Amelia Harvey (Mercer PA) on Jan 19, 2017 7:44:31 GMT -4
I do understand the author’s point of view. The obsession with social media focuses on the information you present to others (number of friends, who you hung out with that day, places you have been, etc.) and instant gratification. I think this sets up an idealization of success based on comparison which can lead to feelings of inadequacy and guilt. However, I think human desire to be perceived as successful by others is constant through generations. Even though awareness of mental health is rising, the isolating nature and guilt associated with mental health issues delays seeking help. As awareness rises though, millennials may be more open with admitting to the depressive symptoms than previous generations. I do not necessarily agree with the generalizations of how this translates to the workplace.
|
|
amber
New Member
Posts: 6
|
Post by amber on Jan 19, 2017 9:40:25 GMT -4
While I agree with the sentiment that millennials have some of the most under reported cases when it comes to depression, I also believe that a lot of the under reporting is because of the stigma associated with having a mental disorder in the work place. Not only so, but the word "depression" has become so over used in every day vernacular, that when people are actually depressed, it is not taken seriously because the word has become a synonym for sadness. Work Culture can also lead to depression because of the strain imposed by well-meaning bosses to maintain perfection, although this is a gargantuan and sometimes impossible task.
|
|
|
Post by Ashley Lentine on Jan 19, 2017 10:27:34 GMT -4
I hate that I am associated with the Millennial generation, I do agree with the fact that they are lazy. This generation has had instant gratification with no concept of winning and losing. They grew up with participation awards where everybody wins, however the real world does not work that way. Not everyone gets a raise or the job they applied for, that's life. But if this is the cause of their "depression" then they really need to grow up. They might say that they are "depressed" or "sad" because they didn't get the job they wanted or graduated from college and didn't immediately get a job. Worse yet, these kids get upset when they do not get a certain number of "likes" on their social media account. The generations before us had to work to get the life they wanted, hence why Baby Boomers think the younger generations are lazy. Why are these millennials saying that they are depressed? I think the root of this needs to be addressed if they are going to make a big hoopla about the poor millennials being sad. The generation seems to expect things to just be handed to them. I do believe there is an increase in depression world wide, but I think more research must be done on this topic to find the causes of the increasing numbers. Overall I found this article interesting yet lacking.
|
|
|
Post by ianjvalmont on Jan 19, 2017 10:29:18 GMT -4
Geez, where to begin. I feel like I'd need to write an article just to discuss this article.
While I understand that it can be useful to break up the population into generations, it doesn't seem well understood that these are arbitrary age groups that are not even universally agreed upon. The downside to breaking up the population into generations is the "Us vs Them" mentality that gets introduced. There is nothing particularly noteworthy about the Millennial generation being labeled as lazy or too self-involved, like the article mentions, because every older generation says that about the generation that follows. So I'm not entirely sure that how the generation is perceived is relevant to the discussion of why is the age group reporting depression at a higher rate.
I haven't seen the studies from which the article is pulling its data so it's hard to see what they've controlled for. My first impression is that perhaps as the perception of depression changes so does a willingness to report it. The article does mention that awareness of the seriousness and legitimacy of depression is an important issue but fails to really understate that awareness and public perception of its legitimacy has steadily improved over time. Perhaps the differences in rates of depression between the generations simply comes down to our changing culture and therefore a willingness to report.
The article brings up social media and its effects on mental health. While I don't deny the negative impact it CAN have, I think it muddies the waters for discussion. Social Media is not exclusively used by the Millennial generation and doesn't always have a negative impact. I think if we were to go back, we could find another instances of a past generations equivalent to "social media" as the new and dangerous thing the upcoming generation is dealing with.
If there was a true difference in the rates of depression between generations that couldn't be explained by a difference in self reporting, I would think it may have more to do with the change in the way young adults enter and navigate the workforce. Long gone are the days of starting as an entry level employee at a large company, moving up the ladder and working there until you die. You can no longer work over the summer part-time and have the upcoming year's tuition paid for. Companies will intentionally keep your hours low as to avoid providing benefits. Many require experience even for entry level positions, rendering the term almost useless at this point. Many baby boomers genuinely do not understand how drastically things have changed since they were in that generation's shoes and the disapproval for their "failure to thrive" is often thinly veiled. What kind of impact does this have on people trying to make it on their own?
|
|
|
Post by Adenike Orogade on Jan 19, 2017 10:52:50 GMT -4
Why Millennials Are Struggling With Mental Health At Work
Mental health in the workforce especially depression to be specific is a manifestation of multi-factorial effects on individuals. This is easily itemized and may not only improve the outlook in life but also boast the productivity of the country as a whole.
To begin with the level of education is a key factor in the opportunities available in terms of job opportunities. A lower level may require either more schooling or more steps towards achieving the desired work.
After getting a job, the question of passion is quickly brought to surface for both the temporary workers and low paying jobs to the veterans that have spent years in one place. A sense of passion and fulfillment can keep an individual happy and hence reduce the risk of mental health issues.
During the working hours the pressure from the job can be a huge cause of depression especially if the demand is not meet by employee. Due to the fast paced nature of the community it is hard to sometimes keep up with ever increasing demand.
Apart to daily stress, I believe that if most of these issues are avoided or addressed; there will be a rapid decline in mental health cases
|
|
|
Post by seunghoonyang (ms4) on Jan 19, 2017 15:59:14 GMT -4
Personally, I have not heard of the term Millennials before reading this article. However, I have to agree that we have been raised in such a way where we are told that everything is going to be okay, all you have to do is participate. Fortunately, many of us have outgrown of the situation and figured out on our own or by help of others that we have to actually do work hard and earn our reputations. It is painful to see when I confront with a spoiled friend who does not take care of the things they need to do. Increased rate of depression in this generation is not unexpected since they want more and more. Happiness and satisfaction does not come from getting what they want, it comes from learning to be satisfied with what they have. You can be happy with nothing on your hand and you can be depressed with billion dollars on your bank account, it is crucial to understand what is important in life and live accordingly.
|
|
|
Post by kaylazodle on Jan 19, 2017 17:10:00 GMT -4
The statistics relating to the increase in the number of people, particularly millennials, presenting with depression is very disconcerting.
I personally believe that millennials are lazy and have a sizable sense of entitlement, however, that does not eliminate evidence of increased incidence of depression in this particular group.
In exploring this topic, I found that there have been many studies regarding millennials and deteriorating mental health. Of these, the common factor was the association with social media.
As a millennial myself, I can attest to spending a copious amount of time on social media, where I would habitually compare my seemingly uneventful life to “everybody else’s highlight reel”. However, once I started medical school those negative feelings gradually dissipated, as my social media use was to a minimum, and any down time I had was reserved for “power naps”. Therefore, I completely agree with the author’s notion that this comparison culture brought about by social media can cause feelings of inadequacy, self doubt and depression.
With regards to work culture, I believe that multitasking between social media and work assignments is detrimental to cognitive function and results in decreased productivity. Therefore more time is spent at work trying complete tasks that would have been completed in much less time if there wasn't the interruption of social media. In my opinion, the increase in hours spent working and decreased sleep can also contribute to anxiety and depressive symptoms. The real question is, is it the work culture or the millennial culture that needs to change?
|
|
|
Post by Fatima Misbah on Jan 19, 2017 17:51:32 GMT -4
It has become increasingly evident that millennials spend a vast majority of their time connecting with “friends” on social media. This can be a major cause of the increasing mental health problems the generation is facing. For many of the millennials social media has become an integrated component of human interaction. Recently researchers at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine conducted a study about the effects of social media habits on the moods of users, which found that the more time users spent on social media, the more likely they are to be depressed. Why does increased exposure to social media cause depression? It could be due to our own exaggerated expectation, and realizing that others are fulfilling their dreams while we are still struggling to launch ourselves. While we see the highly idealized representations of our peers’ lives we get the feelings of envy and the distorted belief that they are leading happier, more successful lives. I believe that distancing ourselves from the distractions of social media is a good place to start about feeling better about ourselves.
|
|
|
Post by knedeff on Jan 19, 2017 18:40:36 GMT -4
I found this article interesting, mostly because it brings to light a real problem going on. I do however feel it only brushed the surface on some of the more important aspects. I agree with the last paragraph in that we need to more fully understand depression and other forms of mental health problems.
While I don’t discredit that social media plays a large role in many people falling into depression, because it does, I feel that social media has made people more open and willing to share, which has probably led to the increased millenial reporting. I feel as though the reporting of depression being so much higher in millenials as compared to other generations is due not only to social media but also to the way it’s defined/perceived across the different generations. I wonder how much can be attributed to the notion that it’s the people who say they don’t have a problem that really do, rather than the ones who say they do.
As far as work culture/environment, I agree it needs a reboot. It has become more and more dependent on profitability by whatever means necessary, as I’m sure the older generations would also agree.
|
|